16. Is donation of sperm/oocytes /embryos anonymous? sperm No/oocytes - /embryos No
With regard to the question of whether sperm donations for MAP purposes may remain anonymous, recourse is made to the ruling of the Federal Constitutional Court which states that the general right of personality (Article 2(1) in conjunction with Article 1(1) of the Basic Law [Grundgesetz – GG]) also applies to the child’s knowledge of his/her parentage and protects against the withholding of obtainable information about one’s parentage (consistent past decisions since the Federal Constitutional Court decision of 31 January 1989 – 1 BvL 17/87 - BVerfGE 79, 256). Therefore, the Sperm Donor Register Act provides that the physician who oversees the sperm donation must ensure that the child will later on be able to find out who his/her father is. Anonymising the sperm donation or the use of pooled sperm for artificial fertilisation is not permissible. According to the Model Guidelines of the German Medical Association on the performance of assisted reproduction, the physician must inform the sperm donor that he/she is required to disclose the name of the donor to the child on request and cannot, in this regard, invoke medical confidentiality.
In January 2015, the Federal Court of Justice (Judgment of 28 January 2015 – XII ZR 201/13, BGHZ 204, 54) ruled that children have the right to ask the treating reproductive health physician or sperm bank to disclose the name of the sperm donor from the medical treatment agreement between the parents and the clinic.
These principles were implemented in the Sperm Donor Register Act.
The same rules apply for the donation of embryos, as far as permitted under the Health Law. The coalition agreement provides for the opportunity to submit information about embryo donations to the Sperm Donor Register, this is subject to ongoing legislation.
Regarding oocytes, German Law does not permit any oocyte donation. Therefore, there is no rule in place to identify the genetic mother of a child born by another woman. Section 1591 of the Civil Code determines legal motherhood in terms of gestation only, the woman who gestates is the mother of the child. Whether a court can require a mother to inform the child about his or her genetic mother has not been tested yet in jurisprudence.
17. Is it possible to obtain information about the biological origin of a child born after gametes of embryo donation?
i. For the child him or herself Yes; ii. For the parents No; iii. For a court No
Pursuant to Section 10(1) of the Sperm Donor Register Act a person who assumes to have been conceived through sperm donation has the right to information from the sperm donor register (limited to the child seeking information or his or her parents as legal representatives of the child underage).
a. Identity of the donor(s)
i. For the child him or herself Yes; ii. For the parents No; iii. For a court No
See response to question 17.
Unlike the child, the legal parents are not entitled to learn the identity of the sperm donor. Pursuant to the data protection provisions under the Transplantation Act, the sperm donor and the legal parents are to remain anonymous to one another.
In case of litigation, courts have to decide on the above-mentioned rights; however, the courts themselves are not intrinsically entitled to request information about the parentage of a child.
b. Certain health information concerning the donor(s)
i. For the child him or herself No; ii. For the parents No; iii. For a court No
Pursuant to Section 2(3) of the Sperm Donor Register Act voluntary information about the sperm donor can be recorded in the sperm donor register. Unless the Donor withdraws his consent to store and use this data, the child is entitled to receive respective information upon request.
c. Other information
i. For the child him or herself No; ii. For the parents No; iii. For a court No
See response to question 17b.
In case of litigation, courts have to decide on the above-mentioned rights; however, the courts themselves are not intrinsically entitled to request information about the parentage of a child.
18. Is it possible to contest maternity and paternity of children born utilising MAP and under which conditions?
German law does not provide for maternity to be challenged. A child’s mother is – also where MAP has been used – the woman who has given birth to him/her (Section 1591 of the Civil Code). In rare cases the woman registered as the mother is in fact not the biological mother of the child; in those cases, however, the correction of the birth register (to replace this woman by the woman who has borne this child) is carried out by the civil status authority outside a contestation proceeding.
In contrast, it is in principle possible to challenge the paternity of children born as a result of assisted reproduction (Sections 1599 et seqq. of the Civil Code). The persons entitled to do so are the legal father, the man who declares in lieu of an oath that he had sexual intercourse with the mother of the child during the period of conception, the mother and the child (Section 1600 (1) of the Civil Code). However, any challenge to paternity by the father and the mother is excluded if they have both agreed to the artificial fertilisation (Section 1600(4) of the Civil Code). A challenge to paternity by the sperm donor fails because he cannot affirm on oath that he has had sexual intercourse with the mother. The child, however, is entitled to challenge paternity if donor-assisted MAP has taken place.