A and Others v. Denmark (1) | 1996

Man infected with HIV through blood transfusion faces years of legal delays

Everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a reasonable time.

Extract from Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights

Background

Mr C. was an electronics technician. He received blood transfusions whilst undergoing treatment in a Danish hospital. The transfusions infected him with HIV.

Mr C. lodged a claim for compensation. The speed and outcome of the proceedings were crucial to him, as he had an incurable disease and a reduced life expectancy. However, his case did not reach trial for over five years. By that time, Mr C. had died of AIDS.

Before his death, Mr C. complained to the European Court of Human Rights that an unreasonable delay in the legal proceedings had denied him justice.

Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights

The European court found that the proceedings had been unreasonably long, and that the authorities had failed to ensure that the case was dealt with speedily. This had breached Mr C.’s right to have access to a court in a reasonable time.

The court also found that seven other applicants in similar circumstances were the victims of the same violation.

Follow-up

The Danish civil courts’ practice was adapted in order to help ensure better compliance with the reasonable time requirement.

Mr C.’s widow was paid 100,000 Danish Krone in compensation.

Additional information

Themes:

Related examples

Fair compensation for victims of infected blood scandal

The European court ruled that Italy’s decision to stop victims from receiving inflation-adjusted compensation breached their human rights. Many relied on the payments to cover ongoing medical costs. The court’s ‘pilot judgment’ found that many others had potentially been affected by the decision, resulting in Italy making back payments totalling hundreds of millions of euros to victims.

Themes: Right to a fair trial Right to property Right to equality and freedom from discrimination Human rights and health

Italy

Justice for the family of asbestos poisoning victim

Hans Moor was exposed to asbestos during his work in the 1960s and 70s. This gave him cancer, which was diagnosed in 2004. Hans Moor died in 2005, aged 58. Just before his death, Mr Moor had brought a claim for damages against his former employer for failing to take precautions against exposure to asbestos. The claim was continued by his wife and children.

Themes: Right to a fair trial Human rights and health

Switzerland

Legal aid system introduced after woman suffering from domestic violence was unable to access the courts

Mrs Airey wanted to be legally separated from her husband, who was allegedly a violent alcoholic. However, there was no legal aid and she could not afford the lawyers’ fees. The European Court of Human Rights ruled that the lack of legal aid effectively denied Mrs Airey access to a court, breaching her basic rights. Legal aid for such cases was introduced in Ireland in the following year.

Themes: Right to equality and freedom from discrimination Right to a fair trial Freedom from violence against women

Ireland

Impact of the European Convention on Human Rights